AlphaMED Resources · https://alphamedicine.uk/Resources/glossary/bolam
Bolam test
The Bolam test decides whether a doctor's diagnosis or treatment met the legal standard of care, by asking whether a responsible body of doctors in the same field would have acted the same way.
Summary
- It comes from Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee, a 1957 case in which the judge, McNair J, set it out in his directions to a jury. The Supreme Court, now the UK's highest court, still calls it the legal test for negligence by a doctor in diagnosis or treatment.
- Mr Bolam had electroconvulsive therapy, a treatment that brings on convulsions, without relaxant drugs or restraint to protect him from injury. The experts at trial agreed that a firm body of medical opinion opposed the use of relaxant drugs.
- Doctors often disagree, and the test allows for that. McNair J told the jury a doctor following such a practice is not negligent merely because there is a body of opinion that would have acted differently.
- Two later cases limit it. Bolitho lets a court reject expert support that has no logical basis. Since Montgomery in 2015, what a doctor tells a patient about risks no longer depends on what other doctors would say.
In practice
- Mr McCulloch, aged 39, died at home of a cardiac arrest in April 2012. A cardiologist had decided not to prescribe anti inflammatory drugs such as ibuprofen, and his family said he should have been told about them as an option.
- On 12 July 2023 the Supreme Court held that deciding which treatments are reasonable options is clinical judgment, so the Bolam test applies. Her view was backed by a responsible body of doctors, so she was not negligent.
- Once the options are narrowed to the reasonable ones, Montgomery requires the doctor to discuss each of them with the patient, with its material risks.
In Hong Kong
- Hong Kong courts may refer to precedents of other common law jurisdictions under Article 84 of the Basic Law, so English cases such as Bolam and Bolitho can be cited there.
- The Medical Council of Hong Kong sets professional standards for registered doctors in its code of conduct. It asks doctors to explain risks of serious consequence even when they are unlikely (section 2.10.3).
Interview questions
- What is the Bolam test?
- Should doctors or judges decide what counts as an acceptable standard of care?
- Two consultants would have treated the same patient in different ways. Does that mean one of them was negligent?
Sources
- The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/26
- The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/128
- The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/1900
- The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/11
- basiclaw.gov.hkbasiclaw.gov.hk/…/chapter4.html
- Medical Council of Hong Kongmchk.org.hk/…/Code_of_Professional_Conduct_%28English_Version%29_%28Revise
How to answer these is in the course
The Interview Masterclass teaches you how to answer, then puts you in front of mock panels marked by more than one mentor. Our offer rate is 93% across all cycles since 2022.
alphamedicine.uk/Services · alphamedicine.uk/Results
More NHS hot topics, medical ethics case studies and medical school interview questions are in AlphaMED Resources, which we add to and update through the application cycle.