Bolitho test

The Bolitho test lets a court reject the expert opinion that backs a doctor when that opinion cannot stand up to logical analysis.

Updated 21 November 2026 (1 minute read)

Summary

  • It comes from Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority, which the House of Lords, then the UK's highest court, decided on 13 November 1997. The Supreme Court now calls it a qualification of the Bolam test.
  • Patrick Bolitho was two when he was admitted to St Bartholomew's Hospital in London with breathing difficulties in January 1984. A nurse called a doctor, who failed to attend or send a deputy, and Patrick had a cardiac arrest that left him with severe brain damage. He died while the case was still going on.
    • The hospital accepted that the doctor was negligent in not coming. The dispute was over causation: whether her coming would have changed anything.
    • The doctor said she would not have intubated him, meaning put in a breathing tube, even if she had come. The hospital's expert said that choice was a responsible one, so the Bolam test decided whether not intubating would have been acceptable.
  • The House of Lords said a court must be satisfied that the experts can show their opinion has a logical basis. Where risks and benefits are weighed, they must have reached a defensible conclusion.
  • It added that it would very seldom be right for a judge to call a genuinely held expert view unreasonable. Patrick's case was plainly not one of those rare cases, so the claim failed.

Interview questions

  • What does the Bolitho test add to the Bolam test?
  • What do you know about the Bolitho case?
  • Should judges ever overrule the opinion of doctors on a medical question?

Sources

  1. go-legal.co.ukgo-legal.co.uk/…/Bolitho-v-City-and-Hackney-Health-Authority-1997-4-All-ER-77
  2. The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/26
  3. The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/1838
  4. The National Archives, case lawcaselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/…/1900

How to answer these is in the course

The Interview Masterclass teaches you how to answer, then puts you in front of mock panels marked by more than one mentor. Our offer rate is 93% across all cycles since 2022.

More NHS hot topics, medical ethics case studies and medical school interview questions are in AlphaMED Resources, which we add to and update through the application cycle.